For South African businesses doing R3m+ a yearCall or WhatsApp 060 019 4998 · Mon to Fri 08:00 to 17:00
ANM Consultants banner: Some jobs lose money quietly. How to work out real profit by job or customer.

How do I work out if a job or customer is actually profitable?

November 15, 2026•7 min read

A job is profitable only if its price, excluding VAT, covers its direct costs and its share of your overheads. Direct costs are materials, subcontractors, hire and labour at full cost per billable hour, not the payslip rate. A customer is profitable when all their jobs, after discounts, extra visits and admin, still clear that bar. For what a discount does to profit, see how much profit you lose when you give a customer a discount.

Sibusiso Hlongwane runs Hlongwane Coatings, a fictional Pietermaritzburg commercial painting company with 16 painters and turnover of R11 million. He is closing the file on a school repaint for his biggest customer. The job sheet says it made R84,462, 47% of the price. His bookkeeper asks a fair question: "If our jobs make 47%, why did the business make 4% last year?"

This article shows how to cost a job and a customer properly, with the numbers from that school repaint.

How do you calculate a job's profit?

Job profit is the price excluding VAT, minus the job's direct costs, minus the job's share of overheads. Work through it in four steps:

  1. Start with the price excluding VAT. If you are a VAT vendor, the VAT you charge is output tax that goes to SARS, and the VAT on your purchases is input tax you can usually claim back (SARS VAT). Use VAT-exclusive figures on both sides. If you are not a vendor, or cannot claim the VAT on a purchase, that VAT is part of the cost.

  2. Subtract direct costs. These are costs that exist only because of this job: materials, subcontractors, equipment and scaffold hire, and the hours your team spent on it, including travel to and from this site, rework and return visits.

  3. The result is gross profit. Gross profit is what the job contributes before the costs of running the business. Gross margin is gross profit divided by the price.

  4. Subtract the job's share of overheads. Overheads are costs that do not belong to any one job: office rent, admin salaries, vehicles, insurance, a market-related salary for the owner (even if you take dividends) and accounting fees. What is left is the job's real profit.

Many job sheets stop at step 3, and price labour at the wrong rate. In the example below, those two gaps explain most of the difference between a job that looks good and a business that earns little.

What should labour cost per hour in your job costing?

Labour should be costed at the full yearly cost of each employee divided by the hours they can actually bill, not at the hourly rate on the payslip. The full yearly cost includes wages, bonuses and your employer contributions: 1% UIF on earnings up to R17,712 a month (SARS UIF) and 1% SDL once total salaries are expected to exceed R500,000 over the next 12 months (SARS SDL), plus your COIDA assessment and protective clothing.

Billable hours are hours booked to jobs, whether or not the customer pays for them. They are what is left after leave, public holidays, sick days, training, travel not booked to any job and weather days. For Hlongwane Coatings, a painter earning R9,000 a month costs R110,160 a year and bills 1,500 hours, so labour costs R73.44 per billable hour. The payslip rate on a 45-hour week is R46.15, so the job sheet under-costs every hour by more than a third. For how to count billable days for your own team, see what a R20,000-a-month employee actually costs your business.

How do you work out overhead per billable hour?

Overhead per billable hour is your yearly overheads divided by the total billable hours of your whole team. Leave out any costs you already charge directly to jobs. Hlongwane Coatings has R2.4 million of overheads and 16 painters billing 1,500 hours each, which is 24,000 hours, so every hour on site has to carry R100 of overhead.

If your overheads grow mainly with labour time, as in painting, electrical and plumbing installation, use a rate per hour. If they grow with job value, for example buying, storing and financing materials, a percentage of price or materials may suit better, and some businesses use both. Pick a method, take the overhead figure from your management accounts, and update it at least once a year.

Rule of thumb: a job covers its overheads only if its gross profit per hour on site, with labour at full cost, beats your overheads divided by billable hours.

Illustrative example: the school repaint

Costed properly, the school repaint made R2,998, or 1.7% of the price, not R84,462.

Assumptions:

  • Price R180,000; materials R52,000; scaffold hire R14,000; all excluding VAT.

  • Four painters for 20 days of 8 hours: 640 hours on site.

  • Painters earn R9,000 a month for a 45-hour week; 1,500 billable hours a year each. Bonuses, COIDA and protective clothing are left out, which flatters the full-cost figures.

  • Overheads R2.4 million a year; last year's profit before tax was R440,000 on R11 million of turnover, with other jobs carrying more materials and subcontract work.

Line

Job sheet

Full cost

Price

R180,000

R180,000

Materials and scaffold

R66,000

R66,000

Labour, 640 hours

R29,538

R47,002

Gross profit

R84,462

R66,998

Overhead share

none

R64,000

Profit

R84,462

R2,998

What the numbers mean

  • At full labour cost, the job's gross profit is R66,998, or R104.68 per hour on site. Overhead is R100 an hour, so the job barely clears the bar.

  • For Hlongwane Coatings, billable hours are a big lever: before the snag visits, at 1,300 hours per painter the same job loses R14,079; at 1,700 it makes R16,057.

  • The job sheet is not wrong about materials. It is wrong about the cost of an hour.

How do you tell if a customer is profitable?

A customer is profitable if the gross profit across all their jobs for the year, at full labour cost and after everything they cost you that never reaches a job sheet, still works out above your overhead per hour. Add up each customer's jobs, then subtract:

  • discounts given;

  • return visits and snag lists not already booked to a job, at full labour cost plus overhead per hour;

  • site meetings and re-quotes by your team, at full labour cost plus overhead per hour (office admin is already in overheads).

Also look at the days they take to pay: that cash shows up in your debtors, not your profit (see why a profitable business can have no cash).

The school asked for two snag visits by two painters, 32 hours in total. At R173.44 an hour for labour and overhead, that is R5,550, which turns the job into a loss of R2,552. To make, say, 10% after overheads including those visits, the job needed a price of R202,835, which is 12.7% more than was quoted.

Contractors often feel this, because return visits and slow payment are common in building and installation work. ANM's page on how independent partner firms support contractors covers the wider picture.

Before you quote your next job

Before the next quote goes out, put these five numbers together.

  1. Take each employee's full yearly cost from your payroll reports, adding your COIDA assessment and other employer costs, and divide by their billable hours from timesheets.

  2. Take the last 12 months' overheads from your management accounts and divide by your team's total billable hours.

  3. Pull the actual hours, supplier invoices and hire slips for your last three finished jobs and compare them with the quotes.

  4. List your five biggest customers with their discounts, return visits and the days they take to pay, from your debtors age analysis.

  5. Ask whoever does your accounting and payroll to report gross profit by job and by customer every month. ANM can connect you with an independent partner firm for accounting and payroll.

Figures checked against SARS publications on 15 November 2026, for the UIF, SDL and VAT rules in force on that date.

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

This is general educational information, not advice for your business. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner; professional services are provided by independent partner firms.

ANM Editorial Team

ANM Editorial Team

The ANM Consultants editorial team writes practical guides on tax, VAT, payroll and cashflow for South African owner-managed businesses. Every rate and rule is checked against SARS and government sources on the date shown in the article. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner, and articles are general educational information, not advice for your business.

Back to Blog