For South African businesses doing R3m+ a yearCall or WhatsApp 060 019 4998 · Mon to Fri 08:00 to 17:00
ANM Consultants banner: Discounts cost more profit than expected. How discounts affect margin and what it takes to recover.

How much profit do I lose when I give a customer a discount?

November 15, 2026•6 min read

A discount comes straight out of your gross profit, because the job's costs usually do not fall when the price does. Divide the discount by your gross margin to see what you give away: 10% off a job with a 30% gross margin costs a third of its gross profit, and you need 50% more work to earn it back.

Kavitha Naicker runs Naicker Aluminium, a fictional Durban company that makes and installs aluminium windows and doors, with turnover of R18 million. Her quote for the windows on 24 townhouses is R529,000 including VAT. The developer's quantity surveyor replies the same afternoon: "Take 10% off and the job is yours. Otherwise we go with the other quote."

This article shows what that 10% really costs, how VAT changes the number, and what to ask for instead.

Why does a small discount cost so much profit?

A small discount costs a large share of profit because it comes off the whole price but is paid entirely out of the gross profit. Gross profit is the price excluding VAT minus the job's direct costs: materials, labour and subcontractors. Gross margin is gross profit as a percentage of the price.

When you cut the price, the aluminium, glass and installers' hours still cost the same. Every rand of discount is a rand less gross profit, and because gross profit is only part of the price, the percentage you lose is bigger than the percentage you give.

Rule of thumb: divide the discount by your gross margin to see the share of gross profit you give away, so 10% off at a 30% margin costs a third of it.

How much extra work do you need to make up a discount?

To earn the same gross profit at the discounted price, you need extra work equal to the discount divided by your gross margin minus the discount. At a 30% margin, 10% off means 10 divided by 20, so 50% more work. For a 10% discount:

  • at a 20% gross margin, you give away 50% of gross profit and need 100% more work;

  • at a 25% margin, 40% of gross profit and 67% more work;

  • at a 30% margin, 33% of gross profit and 50% more work;

  • at a 40% margin, 25% of gross profit and 33% more work.

The lower your margin, the more a discount hurts. Contractors who price competitive tenders on thin margins have the least room to give.

Illustrative example: the townhouse windows quote

The 10% the quantity surveyor asked for would cost Naicker Aluminium R46,000 of its R138,000 gross profit on the job, a third of it.

Assumptions:

  • Quote R460,000 excluding VAT (R529,000 including VAT); Naicker Aluminium is a VAT vendor.

  • Direct costs of R322,000 excluding VAT for extrusions, glass, hardware and installation labour, so gross profit is R138,000, a 30% gross margin.

  • The discount does not change the scope or the costs. Costs that move with the price, such as sales commission, would soften the hit slightly.

Discount

Gross profit

Gross profit lost

None

R138,000

None

5%

R115,000

16.7%

10%

R92,000

33.3%

15%

R69,000

50.0%

What the numbers mean

  • For Naicker Aluminium, 10% off cuts the price from R460,000 to R414,000 and gross profit from R138,000 to R92,000. To earn the lost R46,000 back at that price, she would need 50% more work like it, and that extra work needs crew time, cash for materials and possibly more overheads.

  • Overheads do not fall either, so the R46,000 comes off the business's profit before tax in full. If the job was only just covering its share of overheads, a discount can turn it into a loss; how to work out if a job or customer is actually profitable shows the test.

  • If the real choice is the discounted job or no job, and your team would otherwise be idle, compare R92,000 with nothing rather than with R138,000. The job can still be worth taking, as long as it does not push out full-price work.

  • At 15% off she gives away half her gross profit and would need double the work (100% more).

How does VAT work when you give a discount?

If you are a VAT vendor, only the VAT-exclusive part of a discount is profit you give away; the VAT part is tax you would have paid over to SARS anyway. Agreed before you invoice, you simply invoice the lower price and charge VAT on it. VAT is charged at 15% (SARS VAT), so 10% off the R529,000 VAT-inclusive quote is R52,900, of which R6,900 is VAT and R46,000 is lost profit. If you are not registered for VAT, the whole discount comes out of your profit.

When the discount is agreed after you have issued a tax invoice, section 21 of the VAT Act applies: the vendor adjusts its output tax in the return for the period in which the change becomes apparent and issues a credit note showing the amount of the discount and the VAT on that amount (VAT Act section 21). If the customer is not a VAT vendor, you can only claim the VAT back once you have refunded or credited them. No credit note is needed for a prompt payment discount the customer takes up, if its terms are clearly stated on the face of the tax invoice.

For why VAT is due on invoices your customer has not paid yet, see why you pay VAT before your customer pays.

What can you ask for instead of a straight discount?

If you do give a discount, get something for it that is worth at least what it costs. Options that protect gross profit include:

  • a smaller scope or a cheaper specification that cuts your direct costs by as much as the price;

  • a larger deposit or shorter payment terms, so you are not funding the customer's job;

  • flexible timing that lets you fill quiet weeks instead of paying overtime;

  • a written commitment to further phases or projects at the full price.

Meeting halfway also halves the cost: 5% off this quote costs R23,000 of gross profit instead of R46,000.

Contractors quoting against several bidders often face this request. ANM's page on how independent partner firms support contractors covers the wider picture.

Before you agree to a discount

Before you reply to the request, check five things.

  1. Open the costing sheet behind the quote and confirm the gross margin, using current supplier quotes for materials.

  2. Divide the discount by that margin to see the share of gross profit you would give away.

  3. Check the labour hours in the quote against your overhead per hour, to see whether the discounted job still covers its share of overheads.

  4. Pull the customer's payment history from your debtors age analysis and read the contract's payment clauses.

  5. Decide what you will ask for in return, and put any agreed discount in writing on the quote or, if invoiced already, on a credit note.

Figures checked against SARS publications and the VAT Act on 15 November 2026, for the VAT rules in force on that date.

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

This is general educational information, not advice for your business. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner; professional services are provided by independent partner firms.

ANM Editorial Team

ANM Editorial Team

The ANM Consultants editorial team writes practical guides on tax, VAT, payroll and cashflow for South African owner-managed businesses. Every rate and rule is checked against SARS and government sources on the date shown in the article. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner, and articles are general educational information, not advice for your business.

Back to Blog