For South African businesses doing R3m+ a yearCall or WhatsApp 060 019 4998 · Mon to Fri 08:00 to 17:00
ANM Consultants banner: You can change accountants while behind. What to sort out before moving your books and tax work.

Can I change accountants if my books or tax returns are behind?

November 15, 2026•6 min read

Yes. The law does not stop you changing accountants while your books or tax returns are behind, and waiting rarely makes the catch-up smaller. A new firm will usually quote the catch-up separately, deal first with what SARS is already chasing, such as final demands and unpaid VAT, and rebuild missing records from your bank statements.

Lindiwe Sithole runs Sithole Electrical Contractors, a fictional Vereeniging company that does electrical installations and maintenance for factories, with 25 staff and turnover of R9 million. A final demand from SARS, issued six weeks ago, for the company's outstanding income tax return is still on her desk. Her accountant has not replied in three weeks, the last two VAT returns have not been filed, and the books have not been updated since April. Her instinct is to get things tidy before she moves.

This article explains why that order usually costs more, what a new firm will need, and what gets caught up first.

Can you change accountants while your books or returns are behind?

You can, and being behind is a common reason to change. The penalties and interest keep running whoever your accountant is, so staying put while nothing moves only adds to them.

The business's records belong to the business, and it has to keep them whichever firm it uses, generally for five years from the date each return is submitted; for a return that has not been filed yet, that period has not started (Tax Administration Act section 29). Settle or dispute any outstanding fees with the old firm in writing, so the handover is not held up over an invoice. The new firm will usually ask the old firm for professional clearance, a short confirmation that there is no professional reason it should not act for you.

The steps of the switch itself, including the handover letter and changing the SARS registered representative, are set out in ANM's Accountant Switch Kit.

What does it cost to stay behind?

An outstanding company income tax return costs a fixed penalty every month once SARS has issued a final demand and the company has not filed within 21 business days of it (SARS administrative penalties). The penalty depends on the company's taxable income for the preceding year and keeps increasing for each month the return stays outstanding, for up to 35 months from the penalty assessment, or 47 months if SARS has no current address (Tax Administration Act section 211):

Taxable income, preceding year

Penalty per month

R1,000,001 to R5,000,000

R2,000

R5,000,001 to R10,000,000

R4,000

R10,000,001 to R50,000,000

R8,000

Lower bands run from R250 to R1,000 a month, and above R50 million it is R16,000. Unpaid VAT is separate: SARS must impose a penalty of 10% of the VAT not paid on time (VAT Act section 39), and late VAT also attracts interest (SARS VAT obligations).

The cost that often hurts most has no penalty attached. While returns are outstanding, SARS's compliance profile shows red, meaning the business is not tax compliant (SARS My Compliance Profile). It turns green only once returns are filed and any tax debt is paid or under a payment arrangement. For a contractor that bids on tenders or applies for finance, that can matter more than the penalties. For what to check on eFiling each month, see how to check whether your accountant has submitted everything to SARS.

Illustrative example: what waiting costs Sithole Electrical Contractors

For Sithole Electrical Contractors, waiting four more months to tidy up before switching adds R8,000 in fixed penalties, before interest, and keeps the compliance status red for those months.

Assumptions (illustrative):

  • Taxable income for the preceding year of R1.4 million, so the fixed penalty is R2,000 a month.

  • The 21 business days after the final demand have passed without the return being filed.

  • Two VAT periods unpaid at R80,000 each, R160,000 in total.

  • Nothing moves while the current accountant is not responding.

Item

Cost of being late

Grows each month?

Company return after final demand

R2,000 a month

Yes, for up to 35 months

Unpaid VAT of R160,000

R16,000 penalty

Interest, yes

Books seven months behind

No SARS penalty on its own

The catch-up work does

What the numbers mean

  • Rule of thumb: once a SARS final demand deadline passes, an unfiled company return costs more every month, so waiting while nothing is filed only adds cost.

  • The fixed penalty scales with taxable income. At R6 million of taxable income, the same four months would add R16,000.

  • The 10% VAT penalty does not grow with time and is the same whichever firm files, but interest on the unpaid VAT does, so the useful question is how fast the returns can be filed and paid.

What does a new firm need to start the catch-up?

A new firm needs enough records to rebuild the missing months, and your bank statements are the backbone. Gather:

  • bank statements for every business account, card and loan for the missing period;

  • sales invoices, supplier bills and payroll reports for the same months;

  • the last annual financial statements and income tax return that were completed;

  • SARS letters, final demands and statements of account from eFiling;

  • access to your accounting software, ideally on a subscription in the business's name, so the data stays with you.

Where documents are missing, the firm works from the bank statements and asks you to explain the gaps. Missing supplier invoices usually need to be requested again before the VAT returns are filed, because a bank entry alone does not show the VAT charged. Expect the catch-up to be quoted separately from the monthly fee, because it depends on how far behind you are. ANM's page on how independent partner firms handle SARS matters covers the SARS side of that work.

SARS can remit fixed penalties of up to R2,000 for a first incidence of non-compliance, if there were reasonable grounds and the non-compliance has been remedied. This does not apply to the 10% VAT penalty (SARS penalty remission). Ask the new firm whether a remission request is worth making once the returns are in.

For why the VAT figure can be due before your customers have paid, see why you pay VAT before your customer pays. Once you are up to date, how much to put aside for tax each month helps keep it that way.

Before you change accountants with work outstanding

  1. Log in to eFiling and download the statements of account and every SARS letter and final demand, with their dates.

  2. List each outstanding return: VAT201, EMP201, EMP501, IRP6 and ITR14, with the period and due date.

  3. Download 12 months of bank statements for every business account, card and loan.

  4. Check who holds the accounting software subscription, the SARS registered representative role, the public officer role and, for a close corporation, the accounting officer role, and note anything in the old firm's name.

  5. Ask each firm you speak to for a written catch-up quote, the order it will file in, and the date it expects the compliance status to turn green once returns are filed and any debt is paid or under a payment arrangement.

Figures checked against SARS publications, the Tax Administration Act and the VAT Act on 15 November 2026. Amounts in the example are illustrative.

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

This is general educational information, not advice for your business. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner; professional services are provided by independent partner firms.

ANM Editorial Team

ANM Editorial Team

The ANM Consultants editorial team writes practical guides on tax, VAT, payroll and cashflow for South African owner-managed businesses. Every rate and rule is checked against SARS and government sources on the date shown in the article. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner, and articles are general educational information, not advice for your business.

Back to Blog