
Bakkie: Buy It Personally or Through Your Business?
For most owner-managed companies buying an expensive double cab, owning it personally and drawing a travel allowance works out cheapest, because SARS's cost scale allows more than the company car route leaves you after fringe benefit tax. Company ownership makes more sense for a cheaper single cab, where the company can also claim the VAT.
You know the moment. The dealer's quote for a double cab is sitting in your WhatsApp at R750,000. The old bakkie has 280,000 km on the clock and the clutch is going. Payroll goes off on the 25th, your biggest customer is on 60 days, and the advice at the last braai was "put it through the business, it saves tax."
There are three ways to do this, not two, and the one most owners have never had costed is usually the cheapest. Below we run one R750,000 double cab through all three using 2027 tax year rates.
The three ways to put a bakkie on the road
This assumes your business is a (Pty) Ltd and you draw a salary from it. If you trade as a sole proprietor there is no separate company, so the question becomes how you claim business use.
Structure | How it works | The catch |
|---|---|---|
Company owns it | Company buys, insures, fuels and services it and deducts the lot | Your private use is taxed on your payslip every month |
You own it, company pays per kilometre | Company reimburses business kilometres at R4.95, tax free to you | R4.95 does not come close to covering an expensive bakkie |
You own it, company pays a travel allowance | Company pays a monthly allowance; you claim business travel on assessment using SARS's cost scale | PAYE comes off monthly and the claim only lands on assessment |
You cannot mix the last two on the same vehicle and claim twice, and if the company gives you a bakkie and a travel allowance for that same bakkie, no travel deduction is available at all. Renting your own bakkie to your company does not help either: SARS deems the rent, plus anything the company pays on the vehicle, to be a travel allowance in your hands, per SARS Interpretation Note 72.
Single cab or double cab decides the VAT
The VAT Act blocks input tax (the VAT you paid on a purchase) on a "motor car", and a double cab light delivery vehicle is named in the definition itself. No test, no argument about how you use it. SARS Interpretation Note 82 sets this out.
A single cab is different. SARS's own example in that note has a construction company claiming the input VAT on a single cab bought to deliver building supplies. Club cabs and extended cabs sit in between: SARS measures the length of the passenger cabin against the dedicated load area, and fold-up seats count as passenger space.
On a R750,000 double cab the blocked VAT is R97,826 (R750,000 x 15/115). Two things that do work in the company's favour: it can still claim the VAT on repairs, maintenance and insurance, and when it eventually sells the bakkie there is no output VAT, because a motor car on which input tax was denied is treated as being sold outside the business. We cover leases, club cabs and dealer-fitted extras in can I claim VAT on a double-cab bakkie.
The tax on driving a company bakkie home
If the company owns it and you use it privately, that private use is a taxable benefit on your payslip: 3.5% a month of the determined value, or 3.25% if a maintenance plan was included when the company bought it. Determined value is the original cost excluding finance charges, and it includes VAT only where the company could not claim that VAT. So a double cab is taxed on the full R750,000, while a single cab on which the VAT was claimed is taxed on the price excluding VAT.
Home to the yard counts as private. So does the weekend trip to the coast. A logbook reduces the benefit by your business kilometres over total kilometres, but only when your personal return is assessed. In the meantime payroll withholds on 80% of the benefit each month, or 20% if the company is satisfied at least 80% of the use will be for business, which is set out in the SARS guide for employers on fringe benefits.
There is also a small VAT bill nobody budgets for. Giving an employee the use of a company car is a deemed supply for VAT, so the company must declare output tax of 0.3% a month of the VAT-exclusive determined value. On this bakkie that is about R3,062 a year.
Why R4.95 a kilometre is not the bargain it looks
For the 2027 tax year the prescribed reimbursement rate is R4.95 a kilometre. Paid on logbook kilometres, with no other vehicle allowance, it is tax free to you and deductible for the company, per the SARS rates per kilometre page.
But SARS publishes a second, more detailed scale for claims against a travel allowance. For a vehicle valued between R690,000 and R805,000 that scale gives a fixed cost of R208,106 a year, fuel at 216.5c a kilometre and maintenance at 114.5c. On 40,000 km a year that works out to R8.51 a kilometre, per the 2027 Rate per Kilometre Schedule. Same bakkie, same kilometres, R3.56 a kilometre difference in what you are allowed.
Illustrative example: one R750,000 double cab, three ways
Illustrative example. Nkosi Electrical (Pty) Ltd is a fictional electrical contractor, R14 million turnover, 18 staff. The assumptions:
VAT registered, profitable, taxed at the 27% company rate. The owner already draws R1.2 million in salary, so extra income is taxed at 41% on the 2027 individual tables.
New double cab, R750,000 including VAT, no maintenance plan, bought for cash. Finance charges are excluded.
40,000 km a year, 24,000 km business per logbook (60%).
Vehicle cost spread over five years (R150,000 a year, the passenger car period in SARS Interpretation Note 47) plus R120,000 running costs: fuel R60,000, insurance R24,000, maintenance and tyres R30,000, licence R6,000.
Where the company owns it, the company recovers R7,043 of input VAT on insurance and maintenance, and pays R3,062 of output VAT on the fringe benefit.
Excluded: finance charges, SDL and UIF, recoupment on sale, and provisional tax timing.
The fair comparison counts every rand the business pays out, including the extra salary you need to cover your own side after tax, then subtracts the company tax saved.
Step 1: what each route allows
Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
Fringe benefit: 3.5% x R750,000 x 12 months | R315,000 |
Less business use per logbook (60%) | R189,000 |
Taxable benefit, so tax at 41% of R126,000 | R51,660 |
Per-km route: 24,000 km x R4.95 | R118,800 |
Travel allowance route: 24,000 km x R8.51 | R204,304 |
Step 2: the full year, company against travel allowance
In the company route your personal cost is the R51,660 of tax on the benefit. In the allowance route it is the R65,696 of bakkie costs the allowance does not cover. Either way the business must pay you enough extra salary to leave that amount after 41% tax.
Per year | Company owns | You own, allowance |
|---|---|---|
Vehicle cost (R750,000 divided by 5) | R150,000 | R150,000 |
Running costs, after the company's VAT recovery | R112,957 | R120,000 |
Paid directly by the company | R262,957 | R0 |
Travel allowance paid to you | R0 | R204,304 |
Extra salary to cover your side after tax | R87,559 | R111,349 |
Total deductible spend | R350,516 | R315,653 |
Less company tax saved at 27% | R94,639 | R85,226 |
Plus output VAT on the fringe benefit | R3,062 | R0 |
Net cost to the business | R258,939 | R230,427 |
The third route, reimbursing R4.95 a kilometre, lands at R273,802, the worst of the three. The reimbursement covers only R118,800 of a R270,000 bakkie bill, so R151,200 has to come out of salary that has already been taxed at 41%.
Step 3: what changes the answer
Net cost to the business | 60% business | 25% business |
|---|---|---|
You own it, travel allowance | R230,427 | R290,884 |
Company owns it | R258,939 | R314,868 |
You own it, R4.95 per km | R273,802 | R308,957 |
With no logbook at all, the picture collapses. The company route costs R354,816 for the year, and both personal routes cost R334,068, because nothing can be claimed or reimbursed and every rand has to come through taxed salary.
What these numbers mean for you
The logbook is still the biggest lever. It is worth R95,877 a year in the company route and R103,641 in the allowance route. That is several times the gap between the structures, for a few minutes a day.
The structure is worth R28,512 a year here. Personal ownership with a properly calculated travel allowance beat company ownership at both 60% and 25% business use, mainly because SARS's cost scale values this bakkie at R8.51 a kilometre.
The popular option is the weak one. Reimbursing R4.95 a kilometre cost R43,375 more than the allowance route. On 24,000 business kilometres the two rates differ by R85,504 of allowable cost.
The cab type is a once-off R97,826. That is the VAT locked inside this double cab. A single cab flips several things at once, which is the next section.
Nothing personal is cheap. At 41%, every R1 you spend on the bakkie yourself needs R1.69 of salary.
Two things the table does not show. The allowance route has a cashflow cost: payroll withholds on 80% of the allowance every month, roughly R67,012 of PAYE here, and you only get it back on assessment. And when the company sells its bakkie, SARS claws back the wear and tear it allowed, so the company route's position is slightly worse over the full life than one year suggests.
What changes if it is a single cab
Take a single cab work bakkie at R460,000 including VAT. The company claims R60,000 of input VAT, so the real cost is R400,000. Because the company recovered that VAT, the fringe benefit is calculated on R400,000, not R460,000. At 3.5% a month that is R168,000 a year, and with the same 60% logbook the taxable benefit drops to R67,200, costing you R27,552 in tax.
So the cab you choose does not just change a VAT claim. It changes what you are taxed on every month, and it is the case where company ownership usually wins.
Where to look first
Dealer quote and spec sheet. Single cab, club cab, extended cab or double cab, and the full price including VAT. This sets both the VAT answer and the cost scale band.
Your trip history. An existing logbook, or three months of fuel slips, job cards and site addresses, to estimate honest business kilometres. Home to the yard is private.
Latest management accounts and tax computation. Deductions only save cash if the company is profitable and paying tax.
Your latest IRP5 and ITA34. These show the marginal rate that applies to your extra income.
VAT registration and your last VAT201. These confirm whether input VAT is on the table at all.
Your current payslip and payroll setup. Whether you already have a travel allowance, and at what inclusion rate it is being taxed.
Asset register, finance statements and your loan account. What the company already owns, owes, and has paid on your behalf.
Mistakes that cost owners money
Bakkie in your name, instalments off the company account. Paying an employee's debt is a taxable benefit in its own right, and it turns into a loan account mess at year end.
Claiming the VAT on a double cab. SARS can reverse it, charge interest, and add an understatement penalty that starts at 25% of the shortfall where reasonable care was not taken.
Taking no salary and just driving the company bakkie. With no employment and no remuneration, the company's deduction can be challenged and you can end up with dividends tax exposure on top.
Taking the R4.95 route by default. It is the simplest, and on an expensive bakkie it is usually the most expensive.
Reconstructing the logbook in February. SARS will not allow a reduction without accurate records, and opening and closing odometer readings are the minimum.
Questions to ask your accountant
Using my real kilometres, what does the deemed cost scale allow me against a travel allowance, and how does that compare to the company car benefit on the same bakkie?
Would the actual cost method beat the deemed cost scale for this vehicle, and what caps apply?
If the company owns it, are you writing it off over four years or five, and what recoupment should I expect on sale?
What allowance amount is defensible for my business travel, and at 80% or 20% inclusion for PAYE?
If the company finances it, what does that do to monthly cashflow and the balance sheet the bank sees?
Quick follow-up questions
What if the bakkie stays at the yard and staff share it?
Then there may be no benefit to tax at all. SARS places no value on the private use where the vehicle is available to and used by employees in general, private use is infrequent or merely incidental, and the vehicle is not normally kept at or near anyone's home after hours. All three must hold. A bakkie that sleeps at your house fails the third one.
Can I move my current bakkie into the company?
Yes, as a sale at a realistic market value, with a change of ownership and the bank's consent if it is financed. Price it properly: where a connected person sells at a non-arm's length price, the company's write-off is based on market value anyway, so a padded price buys nothing. The company will also need a business register number from the traffic department before it can be registered as the owner.
What good support looks like for this decision
This should be a short calculation done before you sign at the dealer, with your real kilometres, your real tax rate and the exact vehicle, comparing all three structures rather than the usual two. Then the payroll side gets set up properly from month one, so the allowance or the benefit is right and the logbook actually happens. That is the difference between staying compliant and planning ahead. Many owners have a good accountant who has simply never been asked to run this comparison.
This is general educational information, not advice for your business. ANM is not an accounting firm or registered tax practitioner; professional services are provided by independent partner firms.
